Click here to read the latest PLA update!

Friday, 06 March 2015 09:08

PLA Update: $275 Million PLA Defeated!

Click here to read the latest PLA update! 

Just before Christmas the San Bernardino Community College District handed local, big-labor special interests a present in the form of a discriminatory and wasteful Project Labor Agreement (PLA).

This “agreement”, which will now cover the remaining work to be done under the district’s allocated construction bond monies, is a union-crafted document that forces all workers and contractors to operate as if they were in a union.

View the PLA Update for July 25, 2014 here.

CFEC Crane Logo 2012
June 25, 2014
Contact: Eric Christen
(858) 431-6337 

Mailers Highlight Fairfield City Council Vote to Play Favorites with Local Union Bosses While Wasting Tax Dollars and Discriminating Against Most Workers 

  Coalition Sends Mailers to More than 10,000 Voters Educating Them About Project Labor Agreement's Impact on New Train Station  

Fairfield, CA - This week mailers are being received by thousands of Fairfield voters educating them about the Project Labor Agreement (PLA) that the Fairfield City Council voted to approve "negotiations" on with local union bosses in April for the City's new Train Station Specific Plan. A PLA is a scheme crafted by local union special interests that are solely meant to make it more difficult for union-free contractors and workers to successfully bid work they cover.  

One of main reasons the Fairfield City Councilmembers are pushing for a PLA is local hire. Unfortunately what they fail to realize is three of Solano County's most recent projects have failed to have local subcontractors working on their projects. The William J. Carroll Government Center had 20 subcontractors on it. Out of the 20 only one was from Solano County. The Health and Social Services Building (365 Tuolumne) had 37 subcontractors, only 3 were from Solano County. The $58 million Solano County Claybank Detention Center had 18 subcontractors and none were from Solano County. PLAs don't help with local hire at all so why are we doing another one for the train station under the supposed need for local hire?

"Apparently some of these Councilmembers are not being kept up to date by their union donors as to what the results of PLAs actually are." said CFEC's Eric Christen. "If they were fully informed and saw the evidence of how PLAs harm the ability to hire local workers, most of whom are union-free, and saw what they did to costs they'd probably be less inclined to push this special interest scheme."   

PLAs force all workers to pay union dues, pay into union pension plans, and to be hired exclusively through a union hiring hall. They also explicitly discriminate against non-union apprentices who belong to state and federally approved training programs. For these reasons contractors who happen to be union-free are less likely to bid a project covered by a PLA thus reducing competition and increasing costs.  

The mailer is being sent to voters in the City of Fairfield so that they will be fully educated on what is going on and asks them to contact the City Council and demand that worker rights not be harmed in any "agreement" crafted by the unions. If the PLA that comes back before the Council for a final vote does in fact have the typical discriminatory provisions in it, CFEC and its allies will work to see that it is rejected and will hold accountable anyone who votes for such a document.

To learn more about this issue contact CFEC's Eric Christen at 858-431-6337 or go



CFEC Crane Logo 2012

May 22, 2014

In This Issue
Sacramento City Council Votes 7-2 to Move Ahead with New $477 Million Arena
Cerritos Community College District Board of Trustees Needs to Hear from You to Help Defeat the Proposed PLA on $500+ Million Bond!
CFEC's Updated PLA Blackbook
Join CFEC at the Home of Pacific Rim Mechanical's Terry Broyles in San Diego on June 18th!
Donate Today
Connect With Us on YouTube, Facebook and Twitter
Quick Links
Our Website 
CFEC on Facebook
Join Our List
Join Our Mailing List 
Sacramento City Council Votes 7-2 to Move Ahead with New $477 Million Arena 

Despite protests from citizens who do not believe the City of Sacramento can afford it and contractors who opposed the union-only Project Labor Agreement (PLA) scheme that is being placed on it, city council members voted 7-2 Tuesday night to approve the plan to build the new Kings Arena.

While praise and back slapping was much on hand Tuesday, this "victory" for Sacramento came with casualties, namely taxpayers and the merit shop contractors, workers, and apprentices who have been assigned second class status by the politicians and owners so as to placate union bosses who simply are afraid to compete for the work. 
To date no PLA has been agreed to, let alone made public, and CFEC will continue to monitor its progress. Unions continue to push to have all of the work in the surrounding development placed under a PLA as well and are threatening to hold up the project if that is not achieved. 

Cerritos Community College District Board of Trustees Needs to Hear from You to Help Defeat the Proposed PLA on $500+ Million Bond!

On Wednesday, June 4, 2014, CFEC has been asked to make a presentation to the board of trustees of this college in response to a pro-PLA union presentation made last month. Unions are attempting to place a PLA on the college's new $500+ million construction bond.
CFEC is requesting that area contractors contact the Cerritos Community College District Board of Trustees and let them know that a PLA is bad for taxpayers, workers, and contractors, many of whom will be paying for this bond.
Trustee Area 2
Stay tuned for more information about the June 4th meeting where CFEC's Eric Christen will be making his presentation so that you can join him in support of keeping this work open for all! 
CFEC's Updated PLA Blackbook  

With so many projects under PLA threat around the state it is often times hard to keep track. CFEC has made it easier by creating the first and only, one of its kind "PLA Blackbook" that tracks past and current threats here. Please review it today to see what is happening on the PLA front! 

Join CFEC at the Home of Pacific Rim Mechanical's Terry Broyles in San Diego on June 18th!   

Download the response form HERE 

Donate Today
Whether it is through the use of our emails, weekly newsletters, gatherings, or other tactics we here at CFEC work hard to educate elected officials, business owners, and other entities about the discriminatory and harmful effects of PLAs. We are able to continue these efforts because of the generous support shown to us by our members. Please donate today and help us continue to keep fair and open competition alive. Thank you! 
Donate to CFEC   
Connect With Us on YouTube, Facebook and Twitter

Keep up with CFEC and our efforts over YouTube, Facebook and Twitter. View videos, images, links to articles and have the ability to "like" or comment on what we are currently doing.

Like us on Facebook 

Follow us on Twitter 

View our videos on YouTube 

CFEC Crane Logo 2012
That was fun.
Monday for us at CFEC began with me getting into my car in Grass Valley (think Tahoe) and proceeding to drive 600 miles to beautiful Santa Barbara to fight a PLA on that County's $96 million North County Jail Expansion Project. At 9am the next morning the Santa Barbara County Supervisors discussed the issue and I was there with John Loudon of the California Construction Compliance Group to defend the right of workers, apprentices, and taxpayers in front of a room full of hostile union bosses who were as friendly as they were coherent. The meeting lasted 4 hours and ended with the main PLA proponent on the board promising me that any PLA that was agreed to would not force workers to pay into union health, welfare, and pension plans. Progress.
A few hours later, up in the City of Fairfield, that city council took up the issue of a PLA on their new $80 million train station. Representing CFEC was Kevin Dayton. Kevin was joined by other supporters of fair and open competition who did an excellent job of spelling out exactly why PLAs were not in the best interests of taxpayers and workers. Unfortunately this council, which had never adopted a PLA previously thanks to our efforts and despite union attempts, showed how true the axiom is that says politics is about relationships. Unions have spent years getting to know and elect this current council and the final vote reflected this reality with all 5 council members agreeing to begin negotiations with local unions. 
At 6:30am that same day CFEC's Alicia Pearlman and Nicole Ganz left San Diego via the Amtrak to join me in Santa Barbara for our event that night where we strategized with local contractors about how to best defeat the County's PLA. We had a wonderful discussion about the issue of PLAs and how to fight them. We agreed to meet again but next time make sure that we had more contractors present.
The next morning we headed down to San Diego stopping on the way at the Oxnard School District offices to meet with staff about a PLA that had just popped up there. Union bosses want to do to the Oxnard School District what they did to Oxnard Union High School District apparently and see to it that their $90 million construction bond is worth 30% less. I was pleased to learn that I will be giving a presentation to the OSD Board of Trustees about the issue of PLAs at an upcoming board meeting. 
We then continued our trip down the coast, a trip that was interrupted when I received a call from the Cerritos Community College District informing me that at 6:30pm that night unions would be giving a presentation on the benefits of PLAs. Why? The college in 2012 passed a construction bond worth $350 million, and unions want it all for themselves. The timing was good seeing how I just happened to be driving by the college at that moment. I adjusted my schedule and decided it was a good night to attend a college board meeting.
The skunk at the picnic.
If I thought the Santa Barbara County Supervisor's meeting was one where we were outnumbered, the meeting at Cerritos made that look like a friendly family gathering. 100 union members and a number of pro-PLA elected officials were there to explain why it was such a good idea to discriminate against workers and rip off taxpayers. Being that I'm not exactly unknown throughout the California union community I was greeted with looks and comments that one might expect a 49er fan to receive at a Raider game. In fact I'm pretty sure every single person in the audience was a Raider fan. Never fearing a chance to inject some reason and common sense into a debate I waited my turn to speak and listened to an hour of pro-PLA rhetoric.  
Then it was my turn.
Trying to persuade using reason and motivate using emotion I was given more than 6 minutes to explain exactly why a PLA would be terrible for the college, assuming of course it didn't want to emulate a dysfunctional entity like the Los Angeles Unified School District. I hit every key point and then formally asked to be given a chance to officially present our side at an upcoming board meeting, which the board agreed to!  
Needless to say the walk back to my seat (now occupied by one pissed off union member) was less than comfortable. I'm pretty sure I heard words and phrases that would make a drunken sailor blush. But the key I learned long ago is to not make eye contact and just keep walking. Done.
I was followed back to my car after the board meeting by a group of friendly union members who appeared to want to give me directions home. I thanked them for the great night and proceeded to drive another 100 miles back down to San Diego arriving at 11:30pm exhausted.
1100 miles in 72 hours. That I can handle. 150 pro-PLA union members to two of us. That I can handle. The name calling and incoherent rage. That I can handle. But what makes it tough is having to wonder if the lack of contractor support both physically and financially is a sign that, in these areas at least, I'm just wasting my time.
I know you are busy running a business and taking care of your family.  Me too. I know you don't like to go to meetings and get yelled at, however incoherently. Me too. But I do it because I feel compelled to protect your right to work and because it's my job. I've been doing this for 15 years and we are good at what we do. But we need your support.
Knowing there is the financial backing there to do what needs to be done makes attending these meetings easier. So I'm asking right now if I can count on you?
You can support CFEC in one of three ways:
  1. A one time online credit card donation  TODAY. 
  2. A one time donation via check sent by mail to PO Box 1627, Poway, CA 92074.
  3. monthly donation via credit card or check that you can arrange with CFEC staff that spreads your support out over the course of a year versus perhaps giving it all now when funds may be limited. 
On Thursday I left my office in San Diego after I finished this email and jumped in the car to drive 550 miles back home to Northern California. It was a long drive but one that will gave me a chance to decompress and strategize about how to fight these 4 PLAs, PLAs totaling $500+ million in work(!), so that you have a chance to bid them. Then there are the other 50 or so PLAs CFEC is also currently monitoring. I would appreciate you taking time today to consider helping us help you. That would make my upcoming trips just that much easier and make me feel like these past few days were worth all the effort. 
Thank you.
Yours in the fight,


Page 1 of 10