CURRENT NEWS

At a cost of $620 million, San Diego's planned Superior Court complex downtown should be the best money can buy. The 22-story high-rise is the most expensive of the 41 courthouse projects included in a $5 billion master plan approved by the Legislature in 2008.

When it opens in 2016, the 704,000-square-foot courthouse will contain 71 courtrooms, plus offices.

But one thing it won't have is an underground tunnel to transport prisoners from the central jail across the street, as originally planned. And a promise to tear down the old courthouse, a drab low-rise taking up three city blocks just off Broadway, also will be broken.

SACRAMENTO — California judicial officials quietly brokered a union-friendly pact to govern construction of a new $586 million courthouse in downtown San Diego, marking the first time the state has turned to a "project-labor agreement" at the onset of building a major court facility.

The deal is between contractor Rudolph and Sletten Inc. and the State Building and Construction Trades Council of California.

"I requested that the contractor enter into a PLA with the Trades Council to ensure certainty and timeliness as well as reduce variables in a construction project of this magnitude," state courts director Steven Jahr wrote in an email obtained by U-T Watchdog. "This will be the first state courthouse project on which a PLA is signed."

The Coast Community College District on Wedensday shot down a request to draft an agreement that would pre-negotiate hiring terms with local unions for almost $700 million in construction projects.

The idea has split the Board of Trustees and drawn sometimes-heated debate for months.

And that acrimony could continue, according to one trustee.

Labor agreement bad for schools

Wednesday, 15 May 2013 12:23

Dear MUSD Board of Education,

My name is Eric Christen and I am the executive director of the Coalition for Fair Employment in Construction. CFEC was formed 14 years ago to stand against the waste and discrimination represented by Project Labor Agreements. We are a statewide organization that seeks to educate owners and taxpayers about the true nature of PLAs.

We are disappointed to have learned thatÊyou agreed to a limited PLAÊfor a certain number of projects without consulting our organization. Before you had undertaken such a radical change in the way a school district does business I would have hoped that the board and your staff would have at least taken a moment to research these "agreements." A quick Google search would have revealed not just how contentious they care but how unpopular they are. Eleven entities now have outright banned PLAs in California in just the past 36 monthsÊwhile 15 different states have done the same.ÊJust last June 58 percent of voters in America's 10th largest city (San Diego) voted to ban them. You would also have found how few school districts use them. In point of fact there have been more than 400 school bonds passed over the last 15 years in California. Of those only 28 have had PLAs placed on them. Why is this? What do the vast majority of school districts know about PLAs that you do not?

The California bullet train agency on Thursday defended its bidding criteria for selecting the winner for its first construction contract, saying that the process held down prices and was handled properly.

The California High-Speed Rail Authority has come under fire from critics who assert changes to the bidding criteria could jeopardize the quality of the project. The authority tentatively chose a team led by Sylmar-based Tutor Perini to build a 29-mile segment of track through Fresno even though it had the lowest technical score. The team had the lowest-cost bid, at just under $1 billion.

Changes to the bid evaluation criteria were made public in August 2011 but were not approved by the agency's board.

If the California high-speed passenger train for the 21st century is the vision of America's future, then the future is blind to cronyism.

Critics of the project have claimed for four years that the California High-Speed Rail Authority (CHSRA) conducts its business through backroom deals carried out by executive personnel.

Board meetings often seem to be shams. Inquiries from journalists in traditional news media go unanswered, and critics in new electronic media report hassles in getting records about controversial issues.

Lack of Blacks Hired on Phase I of Crenshaw Rail Project

The Metro Transportation Authority (MTA) pledged significant African American participation during the construction phase of the Metro Crenshaw/LAX Transit Corridor and also signed a project labor agreement to ensure that Blacks received adequate employment representation, but contractors have drastically under performed in the hiring of African Americans in the first phase of the Crenshaw Advanced Utilities Relocation PLA for Targeted Worker Attainment.

According to MTA internal documents obtained by the Sentinel, which revealed the number of individual hires, Blacks ranked lower than any other demographic group.

The San Diego City Attorney's Office has released a project labor agreement tied to the planned $520 million expansion of the San Diego Convention Center, after a local coalition supporting nonunion contractors filed a lawsuit to make details public.

Eric Christen, a spokesman for the Coalition for Fair Employment in Construction, said the group is reviewing the document to determine whether it violates terms of a city proposition passed last year, banning the city from requiring project labor agreements in public projects.

San Diego officials have said the city did not require and was not involved in negotiations related to the pact reached in November between the convention center project's general contractor, a joint venture of Clark Construction and Hunt Construction, and the San Diego County Building and Construction Trades Council AFL-CIO, which includes labor unions.

Convention center labor pact made public

Wednesday, 24 April 2013 14:09

Non-union workers last year staged a protest over a labor pact governing hiring for convention center expansion project. — Lori Weisberg

A labor-friendly pact governing hiring for the planned expansion of the San Diego convention center was released on Tuesday by the City Attorney's office, a day after critics of the agreement sued the city demanding that it be made public.

The agreement, which was negotiated last year between local labor unions and the project contractor, Clark/Hunt, allows for the hiring of both union and non-union workers but guarantees union-level wages and benefits for all those working on the $550 million project.

For five months, the City of San Diego refused to give the public a Project Labor Agreement negotiated for its planned $520 million convention center expansion. This union agreement was reportedly the result of a backroom deal involving top union leaders, but multiple requests for it under the authority of the California Public Records Act failed to dislodge it.

But today (April 23, 2013), the city provided the labor agreement to the public, less than 24 hours after a construction organization filed a lawsuit to get it. Here are some of the twists and turns of this saga, which serves as an excellent case study in how unions manipulate public policy at the state and local level in California.

In May 2012, the San Diego County Building and Construction Trades Council submitted a massive objection under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) against the draft Environmental Impact Report for the proposed San Diego Convention Center Phase 3 Expansion. Four months later, the San Diego County Building and Construction Trades Council submitted another massive CEQA objection against the revised and final Environmental Impact Report, this time choosing the drama of presenting it during a packed meeting at which San Diego port commissioners were scheduled to approve the project. (Attorneys for unions routinely engage in last-minute CEQA “document dumps” at California public meetings in order to intimidate public officials and developers into surrendering to union economic demands.)

Page 1 of 69